My parents’ daughter
you know something? they are not wrong.
if my parents hadn't believed in me enough to send me here, to pay for me to be here, to listen and advise me even when i was completely incoherent, i would be a very different, smaller-minded, and definitely blander person than i am today. you have given me a whole year so far to develop into someone knowledgable. i'm not there yet, but i'm loving every minute of the process.
thank you.
thank you very much.”
“'thank you, mommy and abba.' 'thank you, ima and tatti.'
you know something? they are not wrong."
My father’s father was a carpenter by trade. He fell to his death from the roof of a construction project when my father was only three. His mother was pretty short on funds thereafter, and managed to get him barely enough of a Jewish education to enable him to read the Hebrew alef-bet, more or less.
My mother’s parents, after each trying their hands at a number of trades, including clothing-factory work and tailoring, settled on a life as grocery-store owners. They managed to give their daughter a Jewish education somewhat better than what my father received, but not much.
My parents were determined that their four children would each get a better Jewish education than either of them had gotten.
That’s why each of us had at least four years of Hebrew school, and acquired a reasonable ability to read basic prayerbook Hebrew.
My parents took us to synagogue practically every Sabbath and holiday, even when they, themselves, couldn’t attend with us, work or shopping (in the days when grocery stores weren’t open on Sundays) getting in their way.
We knew that Rosh Hashanah meant dinner with Grandmom and Grandpop, and morning services in shul listening to the blowing of the shofar.
We knew that Yom Kippur meant fasting for 26 hours. We started “practicing” at 10, skipping breakfast first, then eating lunch at 2, then at 4, so that by the time we became B’not or B’nei Mitzvah, we were ready to tackle the entire fast.
We had kiddush in the synagogue’s sukkah on Sukkot, and danced in shul with the sifrei Torah on Simchat Torah.
As we got old enough, each child had her or his own chanukiah (Chanukah menorah) to light.
We sent money to the Jewish National Fund to plant trees in Israel on Tu BiSh’vat, and drowned out the villain Haman’s name in shul on Purim.
We were well acquainted with the sight of our mother boiling silverware for Pesach (Passover). My father read the entire Haggadah, albeit in English, from cover to cover, no matter how many guests left right after the meal.
We knew that Shavuot meant blintzes and rice knishes (a recipe that my grandmother apparently took into the grave with her—I’ve never had rice knishes anywhere but in her home), and the joyous commemoration, the next morning in shul, of our receiving the Torah on Mount Sinai.
We learned Zionism in Jewish day camps and United Synagogue Youth.
Arriving at adulthood, there was much I didn’t know, and still don’t know.
But my parents gave me the tools.
They always encouraged our learning and observance, even when we kids insisted that they stop bringing bacon (our only “pork cheat”) into the house.
They taught us that one can keep growing in observance as adults when they finally went kosher after we’d all moved out of the house.
It’s because of them that I was able to read Hebrew well enough to spend two months learning the Torah reading for the morning of Yom Kippur, which I chanted at my former synagogue for seven years.
It’s because of them that I was able to read Hebrew well enough to spend six months learning the weekday Amidah.
It’s because of them that I went kosher.
It’s because of them that I became a regular synagogue-goer, not just a “High-Holiday Jew.”
It’s because of them that I’ve spent the better part of my adult life becaming a self-educated Jew, insofar as anyone whose People has such a long written and oral tradition and so many members (including many of my fellow and sister bloggers) eager to teach it can be considered self-taught.
Mark/PT, writing about his father, Lester Skier, who passed away on May 18, 2006, the twenty-first day of the Jewish month of Iyar, said of him, "he figured out that the key to having Jewish grandchildren was Jewish education. So he spent every penny he made on tuition to Jewish Day Schools." Mark spoke of how radical it was in the 60s for non-Orthodox parents to send their children to day school. If such a move was considered radical in New York in the 1960s, imagine how radical it would have been in Southern New Jersey in the 1950s. Even the one and only (Conservative) Solomon Schechter Day School in the general area was across the river in Philadelphia, and the only children in our entire Conservative synagogue who attended it were the rabbi’s children. Then, too, my parents were barely able to make ends meet with their kids in public school, so paying tuition was never even a possibility.
I never had an opportunity to attend a Jewish day school.
Nevertheless, I owe everything I am today as a Jew to my parents.
Thank you.
Thank you very much.
10 Comments:
well written and well felt. it's a cycle...a vicious cycle apparently, to judge from the cost it exacts from both ends...parents with holes in their pockets and children who won't understand what it's like till they're parents too...but that's mesorah, isn't it? that's how we are who we are.
Good post.
It is a cycle...although the cycle in America has been more like parent is frum/parent thinks he can pass judaism to his kid without wasting money on tuition/kid loses frumkeit but gets mad when offspring intermarry/non religious kids feel something is missing and somehow find their way back to Judaism/next generation attends jewish schools...
We're still waiting for our son to find his way back to Judaism, hoping that, eventually, he'll feel something is missing. It's the history of both me and the Punster--kid rebels, adult eventually returns. Let's hope that he follows the family "mesorah/tradition."
Beautiful! My Jewish education was what I pursued on my own from my teen years on. My oldest son, now 5, knows the alef-bet and is starting to speak some Hebrew. He gets excited to go to shul and wears his kippah daily "to show that I love being Jewish." We scrimp and save to send him to a Jewish Day School (no idea what we'll do when his brother gets old enough to go to school). Oldest Son is already planning that no matter what he's doing or where he is, he'll come home for Shabbat dinner and chagim. (He's a forward-thinking 5-year old, I guess.)
I don't do all this for Jewish grandchildren (though that would be REALLY nice!), but because *I* love being Jewish and I can't possibly see how I could stand in my children's way of wanting a more Jewish life. I want them to be happy and fulfilled, and I believe their Jewishness and Jewish community can provide that.
Thank you for posting that, and for prompting me to think about why we promote Judaism at home and out, and for whose benefit it is.
Sheyna, it's always nice to hear from someone else who's "playing catch-up." :) And it's a joy when your kids enjoy being Jewish. Our son used to get a charge out of bonking us on the head with the lulav after making the bracha. I'm not sure that was exactly "kosher," but it sure helped him fulfil the biblical dictum "v'samachta b'chagecha (and you will rejoice on your holiday")! :)
Fudge, you spoke of "parents with holes in their pockets . . ."
Mark/PT, you wrote, "non religious kids feel something is missing and somehow find their way back to Judaism/next generation attends jewish schools..."
Sheyna, you told us that, We scrimp and save to send him to a Jewish Day School . . . "
But what about the Jewish kids for whom no amount of money will enable them to go to day school? Our son was turned down by a Conservative day school, and we concluded that we couldn't send him to a non-denominational school, because neither school was "equipped" to deal with children with his particular mix of disabilities. And his lack of social skills--part of the "mix"--prevented him from being able to function in groups such as United Synagogue Youth (we tried twice to get him to participate in USY, but he just wasn't able to deal with more than one friend at a time until he was much older.) How do we pass down the "mesorah/tradition to *all* Jewish children?
Re:
"... parent is frum/parent thinks he can pass judaism to his kid without wasting money on tuition/kid loses frumkeit but gets mad when offspring intermarry/non religious kids feel something is missing and somehow find their way back to Judaism/next generation attends jewish schools..."
You left out the frequent next step in that cycle: "When the next generation attends Jewish schools, the parents object to the kids' bringing home the knowledge and expectations they learn there! (and, therefore, often the parents severely punish and even abuse the kids for trying to actually do what the parents paid for the kids to learn about)
Do you know anyone who addresses those issues? For decades, I've looked for someone who might even want to talk about that. (When you bring up the resulting issues to a therapist, the therapist will suggest seeing a rabbi -- bring it up with a rabbi, and the rabbi will suggest seeing a therapist.)
Kate, I've never been in your boat, but have heard stories of parents who were adamant about their kids not becoming "too Jewish." Heaven forbid a kid should say motzi over bread after coming home from Hebrew School--she or he might get weird looks.
Sorry I can't be of much assistance. Best of luck finding someone who can help.
Rice knishes - I've been hunting for someone othere than myself who had rice knishes in their background.
My Bubby was also the only person I ever knew who made them. Never heard of such a a thing outside our family. Tell me - were they slightly sweet with a flaky dough (almost like phylo)? Were they sort of square - rectangular shaped? Where was your grandmother from - I"m thinking these were distinctive to some regions?
(natalia@arteflamenco.us)
Post a Comment
<< Home